Fender's new American Vintage II '61 Stratocaster - anyone played one?

[Cliff Gress]

They sound good online, but has anyone any hands on experience with this USA model? Some reviews have questioned their QC, i.e., finish smears on the fretboard, little e too close to the edge of the neck.

 

[Aloha_Ark]

I've heard good press about them. The older AVRI sounded MEH to me, forcing me to go further up the food chain (CS and MB). I think the '61 Pure Vintage pickups on the AVR2 are in the same league (or higher) as the '59-'62 Fender pickups I have on a mod shop Strat.
Reviews are mixed about QC (paint overspray). Contact your Sweetwater salesman to handpick a guitar without these problems.

 

[Amp360]

Honestly, I love Fender guitars. I don't think the instruments they've been making for the last ten-plus years have been all that good. For all the talk of Gibson QC, which I haven't really seen much of, FMIC seems much worse and gets none of the internet chatter.

I hope the guitars are nice but you may want to go to Guitar Center and check one out in person just to be sure.

 

[Cliff Gress]

I checked one out. The neck was so thin as to feel toyish. The rest looked pretty good.

 

[somebodyelseuk]

LOL
After playing an R7, everything has a skinny neck, to me. I got a CS '59 Custom Tele a few weeks back. The neck profile is "59 deep C". Play a modern Fender for a few days and it feels big. Play an R7/9 for a few days and it feels small.

As far as 'QC' on Fenders and Gibsons. They're much better than they were 45 years ago, which isn't saying much, admittedly.
My own experience, between '84 and '20, my 'twin humbucker' was covered by a couple of Yamaha SGs and a Tokai. My Gibson experience covered production line guitars made between '74 and '95ish, at which point I gave up trying them. A mate offered me his very nice white '74 LP Custom for £500 in the mid '90s, but I declined, because it wasn't better than my Yamahas. I've tried LPs from various years after, which were nowhere near as good. In 2020, I tried and bought an R9. Finally, I found a Les Paul that was as good (actually better) as the Yamahas. Bought an R7 a year later - equally great.
Fenders... More or less the same story, except I bought a US Tele in the late 90s which has been great, a US Ultra Strat last year and the afore mentioned CS Tele this year. I've found Mexican Fenders tend not to be finished as well as the US stuff, though.
Right, what I've just described covers 40 years and maybe 150 guitars. The two Yamahas SGs are the only Yamaha SGs I've ever played, Mine are spectacular, but are they representative of the entire SG production? I dunno.
I own a '79 Strat that I've had since the '80s. Honestly, it's cr@p, but the other 6 Fenders I have are great. The two Gibsons I own are mindblowing, but the 'I don't know how many' I tried over the years varied between 'meh' to 'burn it'.
When you think about how many guitars Yamaha, Fender and Gibson made over those 40 years and how few of them I have experience of... it's a drop in a vast ocean.
The internet chatter... well, there are many, many dickheads in the world and they all have internet access - I remember a couple of years ago, a kid on here trying to tell a 'world renowned vintage guitar expert' that he didn't know what he was talking about. He didn't imply it, he actually said it.

At the end of the day, there's a guitar shop between what Fender/Gibson/AN Other ships and what you get in your hands. If what you're trying isn't that good, maybe you should be looking at the 'quality' of the guitar shop?

 

[garywright]

“The internet chatter... well, there are many, many dickheads in the world and they all have internet access“
classic !

 

[Wilko]

They're just as good as any strat.

The skinny tapered neck is kind of the point. That's what makes it '61

Besides the body contours not being close to vintage, and that area past the nut that is never shaped even close to vintage.

 

[ppgf]

Honestly, I love Fender guitars. I don't think the instruments they've been making for the last ten-plus years have been all that good. For all the talk of Gibson QC, which I haven't really seen much of, FMIC seems much worse and gets none of the internet chatter.

I hope the guitars are nice but you may want to go to Guitar Center and check one out in person just to be sure.

 

[ppgf]

my experience is 180 degrees from what you wrote. i think that fender is making the finest instruments in the history of the company, right now.